The 2025 Toyota Tacoma i-Force MAX and Tesla Cybertruck are two very different mid-size pickups to hit the market. The Tacoma hybrid combines a turbocharged 4-cylinder engine with electric assistance for practical power and efficiency, while the Cybertruck has a futuristic design and uses innovative electric motors for maximum performance. This guide compares the strengths of Toyota’s proven hybrid technology with Tesla’s electric innovation to help you decide the better choice for your needs.
Powertrain Performance Analysis
The primary difference between the Toyota Tacoma vs. the Tesla Cybertruck is that the former is a hybrid and the latter is an all-electric model. This affects performance and fuel efficiency, so it is worth keeping in mind.
The 2025 Tacoma i-Force MAX features a 2.4-liter turbocharged 4-cylinder engine paired with a hybrid electric motor. Combined, it can produce up to 326 horsepower and 465 lb-ft of torque. This makes it the most powerful Tacoma ever, boasting smooth, almost instant torque from the hybrid system and improved fuel efficiency compared to its gas counterpart. The engine pairs with an 8-speed automatic transmission and standard four-wheel drive for tackling tougher terrain off paved roads. The hybrid achieves a 0-60 mph time of 7.6 seconds, which makes it feel quick and adequate for most everyday driving and road conditions.
The Tesla Cybertruck offers multiple powertrain variants, with the most common dual-motor AWD setup producing 600 horsepower and 521 lb-ft of torque. The top-tier tri-motor version delivers 845 horsepower and 864 lb-ft of torque. Acceleration is impressive, with 0-60 mph times as quick as 2.6 seconds for the Cyberbeast trim, which is incredibly quick for a giant truck of its size. Tesla’s electric drivetrain ensures instant torque and smooth delivery over a broad range of speeds.
Towing and Payload Capabilities
When it comes to towing and payload capacity, the Tesla wins hands down. The Tacoma’s maximum towing capacity is 6,000 pounds with the hybrid i-Force MAX, whereas the Tesla’s maximum capacity is up to 11,000 pounds. The Toyota has a payload of up to 1,460 pounds, while the Cybertruck can carry up to 2,500 pounds, due to its larger size and stronger build.
Despite the Tacoma’s lower towing and payload specs, it’s still one of the best hybrid trucks for towing. Its lighter weight and smaller size make it easier to handle in tight off-road situations, while the Tesla is better suited for hauling heavier trailers, but it can feel like more of a beast to maneuver. For some drivers, this may be an important factor when deciding which truck is better for their needs.
Off-Road and Terrain Performance
Both models hold their own when it comes to off-road capability, just in their own ways. The Tacoma TRD Off-Road and i-Force MAX trims are equipped with specialized off-road suspension, skid plates, Crawl Control, Multi-Terrain Select, and massive 33-inch tires. It offers excellent performance in even the most rugged conditions. Its nimble footprint, durable build, and proven suspension components make it a favorite among off-road enthusiasts.
Tesla’s Cybertruck has an adjustable air suspension system, four-wheel steering, and “Wade Mode” for water fording, which allows the truck to drive through shallow water. It’s designed for rock crawling and trail performance with high ground clearance but is heavier and larger than the Tacoma, which may affect it’s agility in narrow or technical trails. The Tacoma, in comparison, has a compact frame and refined off-road tuning that gives it an edge on more technical trails.
Pricing and Value Proposition
The Toyota Tacoma i-Force MAX starts at around $47,815 MSRP for the TRD Sport, offering a good balance of power, hybrid efficiency, off-road capability, and traditional pickup utility. The Tesla Cybertruck’s starting MSRP is significantly higher, at $72,235, reflecting its advanced electric technology and premium features. The TRD Off-Road model generally offers the best value with its composite front skid plate for extra underbelly protection and 17-inch wheels with all-terrain tires. The Audio Multimedia Upgrade package is worth the extra cost as it replaces the TRD Off-Road’s standard 8.0-inch screen with a larger 14-inch one.
That being said, there is a flip side to the coin. Tacoma owners benefit from lower maintenance costs associated with proven hybrid technology and an extensive dealer network. Fuel savings are moderate but steady with the hybrid system. The Cybertruck offers zero gas costs but comes with maintenance considerations unique to electric vehicles (mainly battery care, such as monitoring its charge to take care of the battery’s health and longevity) and higher insurance costs.
In terms of value, driving range is often the top priority for the Cybertruck, so it may be best to opt for the more affordable all-wheel drive model, which offers slightly more real-world range and, with a 3.9-second 0-60 mph time, remains very fast.
Final Verdict: Which Truck Wins in 2025?
Both are excellent options, but the 2025 Toyota Tacoma i-Force MAX is the smarter choice for buyers who want proven reliability, the versatility of a pickup, and impressive hybrid power with strong off-road capability, all for a reasonable price point. It suits those who want a practical truck for work and adventure without paying a premium for an EV.
The Tesla Cybertruck offers groundbreaking electric performance, unmatched towing, and futuristic features, but demands a higher upfront investment. For most drivers looking for a balance of usability and value, the Toyota hybrid Tacoma i-Force MAX is the ideal choice for a hybrid-powered mid-size pickup. Want to experience the Tacoma hybrid for yourself? Visit Longo Toyota of Prosper for a test drive today.
Connect with us
